Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI Between $800,000 to $1,000,000

< Back to all Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI

Be the First to Know About New The Peninsula Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else

$$AREACOMMUNITIES$$

The Peninsula Real Estate Map Search

Search by Price

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

All The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI Homes for Sale Between $800,000 to $1,000,000

$869,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 26047175 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

NOSTALGIA MADE MODERN This is a traditional bungalow thoroughly updated for modern living. A cottage that looks/feels like it did when it was built in the 1950's (guessing date) with great wooden floors and wood trim everywhere. Original exterior wood siding is in great condition newly painted. What you will not notice is that the owners took everything apart in the house so they could put the house back together with all NEW plumbing, NEW HVAC equipment and some ductwork, NEW electric, NEW insulation, and storm windows. They rebuilt the kitchen. Kept the original real wood cabinets but put in all new appliances. NEW kitchen floor. They updated the previously enclosed back porch for your den or TV room. BUT THE BEST THING is that you are only minutes from wonderful City BEACH (SEE AERIAL PHOTO) where you have FREE PARKING. First class restaurants and stores all in walking distance. FURNITURE SHOWN IS AI Large parcel ( 198 feet on Barker St) has been formally divided into two separate lots so you can create a family compound with two main houses and a small ADU The grotto, 10 feet down into the ground, was created from a previous creek. It is a place where you can sit, watch the water go by and escape the world completely if you leave your phone in the house. Grotto is surrounded by trees and bushes so it is hidden from the street. Large incomplete building out back can become the basis for an inground swimming pool or a great building for a shop to make things. Or a garage for cars plural. Water and sewer piped from the house into the incomplete building so you can have a bath for whatever you create. Basement has been cleaned and with all new utilities it can become a great space for the kids to go make noise. Just like it was 70 years ago. Golf cart is for sale at $5,000. Sauna also for sale at $5,000.

308 S Barker Street, New Buffalo

$805,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 26046419 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

This lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated 5-bedroom, 3-bath home delivers the space, character, and location that captures the essence of living in one of the Midwest's premier lakeside communities: New Buffalo, MI. Inside, you will find a traditional floor plan with modern touches. Shiplap and wrought iron accents adorn the entry stairway. The main level provides a cozy sitting room, a large living room with abundant natural light, a formal dining room that leads to the family room, and French door access to the back deck. Perfect for entertaining on warm summer evenings! The kitchen offers timeless style with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, tile flooring, cream cabinets with antique accent and plenty of room to gather. With generous living spaces, the home offers flexibility for working from home, and weekend getaways. Outside, the extra-large city lot has been meticulously landscaped and offers easy access to downtown attractions. There's room for a future pool, an expansive deck with space for outdoor dining, a two-car detached garage with bonus space, and a custom 16' x 16' shed for even more storage. Whether you're looking for a full-time home, a weekend retreat, or simply more room to enjoy life near Lake Michigan, this idyllic New Buffalo city home- is the true slice of Americana you've been waiting for!

404 S Berrien Street, New Buffalo

$950,000

26045400 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

A once-in-a-generation opportunity to own an estate homesite with Two fully permitted ready to build lots. Only moments from Lake Michigan, this rare estate-parcel unites Lot 1 and 2 into more than .63 acres showcasing sweeping Lake Michigan views and effortless access to a sandy beach. The property offers flexibility with Two Fully EGLE approved lots or opportunity for the buyers to go through the permitting process for one larger estate home. This provides unmatched architectural flexibility, privacy, and design potential. Ideal for a large legacy home, family compound, or architect driven project. Estate parcels of this size, location, and regulatory certainty are exceptionally rare along Lake Michigan. Property offers beach access without the need to drive. Take advantage of the panoramic views of Lake Michigan and close-by Stop 42 with its beautiful sandy beach. The two fully permitted lots by EGLE and Berrien County, eliminating 12 -24 months of environmental reviews, engineering surveys and related expenses. Buyers can move directly into the design and building phase with confidence. Lot 1 ready-to-build homesite is over .31 acres, has a natural slope behind the footprint that provides exceptional privacy and the potential for a terrace garden or a lower-level deck or gazebo. Lot 2 offers over .32 acres, and Lake Michigan views. Enjoy community activities or pick up a game of pickle ball with your fellow neighbors at the Community Center. SW Michigan offers a relaxed way of life with beaches, golf courses, parks and this property is located just a few minutes from New Buffalo restaurants and shopping. Less than 60 minutes to downtown Chicago.

V/L 1 & 2 Ponchartrain Drive, New Buffalo

$895,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 26045157 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE BACKUP Status ⋅ Forest Beach BLDG.

Situated just steps from the beach, this extraordinary end unit villa offers the perfect blend of luxury and serenity. So close to the shoreline, you can easily hear the soothing sound of the waves. Enjoy sunbathing on the beach chairs, gather around a beach fire, or revel in the breathtaking sunsets over Lake Michigan. This stunning 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom villa provides ample space for family and guests. The beautiful hardwood floors add elegance throughout the home, while the large, bright, and open kitchen becomes the heart of the house, perfect for entertaining and family gatherings. The villa features a cozy fireplace and a family room, providing plenty of space for relaxation and entertainment. Outdoor decks allow you to enjoy the serene surroundings. It has a 1-car garage and is located a short distance from all the Forest Beach amenities, where you can enjoy the park, pool, tennis, and basketball courts. This villa offers peaceful surroundings! Make an appointment to see!

18400 Dunecrest Drive Unit 6, New Buffalo

$895,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 26039005 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Reimagined for elevated Lake Michigan living, this spacious three-bedroom, three-bath Michiana retreat features a dedicated office, a new kitchen, fresh paint throughout, updated flooring and newly designed landscaping. The private resort-style deck—with gazebo, fireplace and hot tub—creates an effortless setting for summer entertaining. Positioned beside Michiana Village Park and approximately four minutes from Stop 40, the home places the beach and golf-cart-friendly community within easy reach. New Buffalo's harbor, distinctive restaurants, boutiques, wineries and breweries are just minutes away, while downtown Chicago is approximately 70 miles from your door. Polished and exceptionally well located, this is the increasingly rare Harbor Country escape that feels worlds away without sacrificing access. Opportunities offering this combination of space, setting and lifestyle do not linger. Basement has two rooms that could be counted as bedrooms with the addition of egress windows.

4035 Choctaw Trail, New Buffalo

$899,000

26036749 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Opportunity to own 14.47 acres in New Buffalo Township featuring more than 5 acres of private pond frontage. Zoned Agricultural/Residential, the property offers a variety of potential uses, including a private estate, hobby farm, recreational retreat, or possible subdivision (subject to township approval). Enjoy a peaceful setting just minutes from downtown New Buffalo, Lake Michigan beaches, restaurants, and shopping, with convenient access to I-94 for an easy commute to Chicago or Southwest Michigan destinations. A unique opportunity to own a large parcel with water, privacy, and future potential in one of the area's most sought-after locations.

11930 Wilson Road, New Buffalo

Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.