The Peninsula Real Estate

Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI Between $400,000 to $600,000

< Back to all Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI

Be the First to Know About New The Peninsula Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else
$$AREACOMMUNITIES$$

The Peninsula Real Estate Map Search

Search by Price
  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

All The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI Homes for Sale Between $400,000 to $600,000

221 S Taylor Street, New Buffalo
$575,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 26056802 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Beautifully renovated and move-in ready, this 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom New Buffalo home offers an exceptional combination of modern finishes, thoughtful improvements, and versatile living space. The spacious main level features an inviting living area, updated flooring, fresh paint, and contemporary lighting throughout. The beautifully renovated kitchen showcases quartz countertops, custom tile work, open wood shelving, stainless steel appliances, and abundant cabinetry. All three bathrooms have been completely transformed with stylish finishes and custom tile work. The expansive finished lower level provides an incredible extension of the home's living space perfect for entertaining, relaxing or a private guest area. Featuring a large recreation room full bathroom, and private sauna for relaxing, and a laundry room. Beyond the beautiful interior, extensive improvements include a new roof with new decking and insulation, new soffits, fascia, and gutters. a new HVAC system, and a custom-built front porch. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a Southwest Michigan retreat, this thoughtfully renovated home offers the comfort, flexibility, and convenience of being close to downtown New Buffalo, Lake Michigan beaches, restaurants, shopping, and more. Enjoy the best of Harbor Country living without the need for renovations!

221 S Taylor Street, New Buffalo
124 S Mayhew Street, New Buffalo
$495,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 26056787 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Discover the charm of this inviting 3 bedroom, 2 full bath New Buffalo home, perfectly situated and close to enjoy everything this sought-after area of Harbor Country has to offer! The main floor features an open living and dining area, with beautiful hardwood floors, and a functional, galley kitchen and laundry plus a full bath. The upstairs has 2 bedrooms plus a primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and full bath. Recent updates include a newer furnace (2023) and roof (2014). Step outside to enjoy the large fenced backyard, brick paver, covered patio with lighting and a ceiling fan, and a spacious storage shed. With comfortable living spaces, outdoor room to relax and entertain, and a convenient location, just a short distance from downtown New Buffalo, local restaurants, shopping, and the Lake Michigan Public Beach, this home is a wonderful opportunity for a year round residence, weekend getaway or investment property!

124 S Mayhew Street, New Buffalo
300 Oselka Drive Unit 161, New Buffalo
$490,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 26056524 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ Southcove Replat BLDG.
Morning coffee overlooking the marina. Lunch downtown. Sunset on the beach. At 300 Oselka Drive, Unit 161, the New Buffalo waterfront lifestyle is part of your everyday routine. Freshly painted and turnkey, this ground-floor South Cove condominium features new carpet, new hardwood flooring in the foyer, new full-size stackable washer and dryer, custom-made draperies, and a new water heater. All light fixtures and cabinet hardware are brand new, and a 55-inch new TV is included. The enclosed porch overlooking the marina offers an inviting place to relax and watch the harbor come to life. A fireplace, in-unit laundry, assigned parking, and an association pool complete the easy lake-living experience. Walk to downtown New Buffalo's restaurants, cafés, boutiques, New Buffalo Yacht Club, and sandy public beach. Whether enjoying a weekend escape or year-round living, this marina-side retreat places the best of Harbor Country close to home.

300 Oselka Drive Unit 161, New Buffalo
446 E Buffalo Street, New Buffalo
$475,000
26054514 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

446 E Buffalo Street, New Buffalo
46351 Grand Beach Road, New Buffalo
$479,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 26052397 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE BACKUP Status
GRAND BEACH...Classic sunny vintage beach bungalow with wide open mid century vibe. Open staircase separates a spacious country kitchen & a vaulted living room with a modern tile fireplace. Lives LARGE, bright & cheery with one bed & bath on the main level, and a artsy upstairs open loft bedroom with a second full bath up. A three season porch adds indoor living space plus an outdoor grilling deck overlooking a very charming oversized lawn & green space with a firepit - PLUS a additional screened porch adds yet a third comfy living space. LOTS of places to relax in this true get-away - all just a few minutes golf cart or bike ride to Lake Michigan beaches & the Harbor Country bike path. 75 minutes from Chicago/ a few miles to downtown New Buffalo OR downtown Michigan City & Harbor - and 35 minutes from South Bend / Notre Dame. YES - STR Permit already in use with $35k+ extra income

46351 Grand Beach Road, New Buffalo
14440 Ridgeview Drive, New Buffalo
$550,000
26049707 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Envision a custom home surrounded by mature trees, with deeded access to a sandy association beach just about a block away. Offering approximately 0.36 acres across three lots, 14440 Ridgeview Drive provides a cleared building area and natural privacy created by the incline at the rear of the property. A thoughtfully designed home may capture limited seasonal views of Lake Michigan. The site previously received EGLE approval; the buyer will be responsible for obtaining a new permit. An exceptional Michiana setting for a weekend retreat or year-round home near downtown New Buffalo.

14440 Ridgeview Drive, New Buffalo
Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!