The Peninsula Real Estate

5 Bathroom Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI

< Back to all Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI

Be the First to Know About New The Peninsula Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else
$$AREACOMMUNITIES$$

The Peninsula Real Estate Map Search

Search by Bathrooms
  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

All 5 Bathroom Homes for Sale in The Peninsula, New Buffalo, MI

19103 White Pine Drive Unit 8, New Buffalo
$1,499,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26055573 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Welcome to White Pine, a wooded enclave offering resort-style living in the heart of Southwest Michigan's Harbor Country. It is just minutes from Lake Michigan's sandy beaches and local shops, restaurants, and the Amtrak to Chicago. Set across 22 meandering acres, this thoughtfully planned community features 22 oversized, wooded homesites surrounded by serene natural beauty, with more than 10 acres of shared green space. Enjoy scenic walking paths lined with wildflowers, a stocked fishing pond, an outdoor gathering patio, a screened-in porch, and a resort-style community pool with a dedicated lap lane and lounging shelf. White Pine offers a tranquil contemporary retreat where nature, relaxation, and community come together. White Pine is the perfect setting for a weekend getaway, peaceful year-round living. Furniture is negotiable.

19103 White Pine Drive Unit 8, New Buffalo
116 N Smith Street, New Buffalo
$1,400,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26052678 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY Turnkey summer rental (Freshwater Vacation Rentals) in the heart of New Buffalo with an ACTIVE STR PERMIT. 116 N Smith offers 6 beds and 4.5 baths across a main house plus separate pool house, with 4 main-level bedrooms, private heated pool, 2023 hot tub, screened porch and bar/game room on a level half-acre lot. Minutes to the beach, shops, dining and marina. Strong rental history with high occupancy makes this a proven Harbor Country investment.

116 N Smith Street, New Buffalo
331 Marquette Drive, New Buffalo
$3,500,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26049868 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE BACKUP Status
A rare opportunity to own one of Harbor Country's most unique waterfront properties! This custom 6br/4.5ba home on .95 acre overlooks the Galien River and offers a private boat dock with power and water, plus deeded beach rights to Wolverine Beach. Gorgeous antique barn beams frame the spacious and nicely appointed eat-in kitchen, which opens to a deck overlooking the backyard and Galien River. The open living area is anchored by a stone fireplace and opens to the huge screen porch with a fireplace and built-in grill. Main level primary suite offers two full baths and opens to its own screen porch. Generous lower level has walkout rec room, spacious family room with a wet bar, two bedrooms, large full bath, work room, and opens to the patio and outdoor shower. The large backyard is pool ready! Be on Lake Michigan in 5 minutes by boat, or make the short trip to downtown New Buffalo for dining and shops. Over 40' dock offers tons of options for multiple watercraft!

331 Marquette Drive, New Buffalo
108 N Barton Street, New Buffalo
$1,350,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26043286 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
RARE NEW BUFFALO SHORT-TERM RENTAL OPPORTUNITY! BLOCK OUT YOUR OWN DATES AND RENT THE REST! Enjoy the flexibility of owning a furnished vacation getaway with established rental history in one of New Buffalo's most desirable downtown locations. With new short-term rentals restricted in residential zoning districts, opportunities to purchase an established STR are increasingly limited. This charming circa-1890 Victorian is just steps from downtown restaurants, shopping, the marina, Amtrak station and Lake Michigan beach. Featuring 5 bedrooms and 4.5 baths across three finished levels, the home offers plenty of space for family getaways, entertaining and rental guests. A main-level bedroom with its own full bath, flexible den and finished third floor provide versatile accommodations. Outdoor living includes a covered front porch, side porch, screened back porch, deck and outdoor shower. A rare 5-car garage is an exceptional convenience in downtown New Buffalo! Historic charm meets modern updates with newer HVAC, plumbing, electrical, replacement windows and doors, and a 2018 roof. Detailed millwork, crown molding and substantial trim preserve the home's Victorian character. FULLY FURNISHED WITH ESTABLISHED RENTAL HISTORY! Whether you're looking for your own Lake Michigan retreat, rental income potential or both, this property offers a unique opportunity in the heart of New Buffalo. Buyer to verify STR eligibility, permit renewal requirements and zoning with the City.

108 N Barton Street, New Buffalo
18353 Forest Beach Drive, New Buffalo
$2,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26027872 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Nestled in a lush, park-like setting, this stunning custom-built traditional home offers the perfect blend of elegance and comfort. Featuring over 6,300 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, the open-concept floor plan showcases soaring vaulted ceilings, rich hardwood floors, and abundant natural light. The inviting great room features a gas fireplace and arched windows, flowing seamlessly into the dining area. The gourmet kitchen is appointed with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances. The luxurious primary suite includes a spa-inspired bath, while three additional bedrooms are located upstairs. With 5 bedrooms and 4.5 baths, there's room for everyone. Enjoy outdoor living on the expansive paver patio. Located in the gated Forest Beach Estates community, residents enjoy access to a private beach, tennis and basketball courts. Over $300,000 recently invested, including new roof, HVAC and interior finishes.

18353 Forest Beach Drive, New Buffalo
210 E Water Street, New Buffalo
$2,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26021952 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
''Harbor House'' a custom built home with sweeping views of the 1,000 acre Galien River Nature Preserve & the New Buffalo marina. Enjoy nature from the multiple mahogany decks & screened porch or watch sunsets over the harbor in front of the outdoor fireplace. This home offers breathtaking views from every room. Vaulted Great Room with stone fireplace, gourmet kitchen with granite counters & S/S appliances. Primary bedroom suite has Jacuzzi tub, walk-in shower & large walk-in closet. 3 additional bedrooms with ensuite baths. Mahogany floors throughout the main level. New tankless hot water heater, surround sound, security system and 2 car heated garage. Steps to your own private 45' boat slip. Just a four minute walk to the beautiful Lake Michigan beach. Great rental history with permit.

210 E Water Street, New Buffalo
Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!