New Buffalo Real Estate

5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in New Buffalo, MI

< Back to all Homes for Sale in New Buffalo, MI

Be the First to Know About New New Buffalo Homes

Stay ahead with real-time updates — no searching required.

See Homes Before Everyone Else
$$AREACOMMUNITIES$$

New Buffalo Real Estate Map Search

Search by Bedrooms
  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

All 5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in New Buffalo, MI

$2,488,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 26047784 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Experience refined Harbor Country living in this exceptional custom residence built in 2021 within the gated community of The Preserve on the Galien. Offering approximately 5,000 square feet of impeccably designed living space, this luxury retreat is surrounded by protected wetlands, mature woodlands, and scenic walking trails, yet remains just minutes from Lake Michigan, downtown New Buffalo, marinas, restaurants, and shopping. Designed for both elegant entertaining and comfortable everyday living, the home features soaring ceilings, a dramatic great room, a chef's kitchen with custom cabinetry and an oversized gathering island, and a spectacular four-season room with fireplace and walls of glass that bring the outdoors in year-round. The thoughtfully designed floor plan includes a main-level primary suite, guest suite, and laundry, while the upper level offers two additional bedrooms, two baths, second laundry, and an expansive game and bunk room retreat. Outdoor amenities include a private patio with hot tub, custom putting green, and fire pit gathering area, creating the perfect setting for relaxation and entertaining. Need additional bedrooms, a home office, or private den? The flexible upper-level layout can be easily reconfigured to meet your needs, with virtual concept renderings available to showcase potential room modifications. An oversized crawl space provides exceptional storage for beach gear, bicycles, and seasonal furnishings. Enjoy Lake Michigan boating without the ownership hassle--seller is offering a 2-year Carefree Boat Club membership with an acceptable offer. A rare opportunity to own one of Harbor Country's finest luxury properties.

7 Preserve Way, New Buffalo
$805,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 26046419 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
This lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated 5-bedroom, 3-bath home delivers the space, character, and location that captures the essence of living in one of the Midwest's premier lakeside communities: New Buffalo, MI. Inside, you will find a traditional floor plan with modern touches. Shiplap and wrought iron accents adorn the entry stairway. The main level provides a cozy sitting room, a large living room with abundant natural light, a formal dining room that leads to the family room, and French door access to the back deck. Perfect for entertaining on warm summer evenings! The kitchen offers timeless style with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, tile flooring, cream cabinets with antique accent and plenty of room to gather. With generous living spaces, the home offers flexibility for working from home, and weekend getaways. Outside, the extra-large city lot has been meticulously landscaped and offers easy access to downtown attractions. There's room for a future pool, an expansive deck with space for outdoor dining, a two-car detached garage with bonus space, and a custom 16' x 16' shed for even more storage. Whether you're looking for a full-time home, a weekend retreat, or simply more room to enjoy life near Lake Michigan, this idyllic New Buffalo city home- is the true slice of Americana you've been waiting for!

404 S Berrien Street, New Buffalo
$895,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 26045157 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE BACKUP Status ⋅ Forest Beach BLDG.
Situated just steps from the beach, this extraordinary end unit villa offers the perfect blend of luxury and serenity. So close to the shoreline, you can easily hear the soothing sound of the waves. Enjoy sunbathing on the beach chairs, gather around a beach fire, or revel in the breathtaking sunsets over Lake Michigan. This stunning 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom villa provides ample space for family and guests. The beautiful hardwood floors add elegance throughout the home, while the large, bright, and open kitchen becomes the heart of the house, perfect for entertaining and family gatherings. The villa features a cozy fireplace and a family room, providing plenty of space for relaxation and entertainment. Outdoor decks allow you to enjoy the serene surroundings. It has a 1-car garage and is located a short distance from all the Forest Beach amenities, where you can enjoy the park, pool, tennis, and basketball courts. This villa offers peaceful surroundings! Make an appointment to see!

18400 Dunecrest Drive Unit 6, New Buffalo
$1,550,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26043286 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Own a piece of New Buffalo history and enjoy the best of both worlds—a distinctive second home with an established short-term rental history.Dating to approximately 1890, this beautifully preserved Victorian blends historic character with the space, updates and location today's buyers are looking for. Offering more than 3,250 square feet of finished living space across three levels, the home features 5 bedrooms and 4.5 baths, including a main-level bedroom and full bath suite, along with a flexible main-level den and fully finished third floor—ideal for a home office, recreation room or guest accommodations. Thoughtful improvements have modernized the home while preserving the architectural details that make it special, including updated HVAC, plumbing and electrical, replacement windows and doors, and a roof installed in 2018. Detailed millwork, generous crown molding and substantial trim add warmth, character and a sense of history throughout. Located in the heart of New Buffalo's Central Business District, the home is within walking distance of downtown dining and shopping, the Amtrak station, marina and Lake Michigan beach. There are very few single-family homes with such a short walk to everything New Buffalo has to offer. With an established short-term rental history, this property offers a unique opportunity to enjoy your own New Buffalo retreat while having the flexibility to generate rental income when you're not using it. Whether you're looking for a second home, an investment property, or the perfect combination of both, this is a rare chance to own an exceptional piece of New Buffalo history.

108 N Barton Street, New Buffalo
$2,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 26027872 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Nestled in a lush, park-like setting, this stunning custom-built traditional home offers the perfect blend of elegance and comfort. Featuring over 6,300 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, the open-concept floor plan showcases soaring vaulted ceilings, rich hardwood floors, and abundant natural light. The inviting great room features a gas fireplace and arched windows, flowing seamlessly into the dining area. The gourmet kitchen is appointed with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances. The luxurious primary suite includes a spa-inspired bath, while three additional bedrooms are located upstairs. With 5 bedrooms and 4.5 baths, there's room for everyone. Enjoy outdoor living on the expansive paver patio. Located in the gated Forest Beach Estates community, residents enjoy access to a private beach, tennis and basketball courts. Over $300,000 recently invested, including new roof, HVAC and interior finishes.

18353 Forest Beach Drive, New Buffalo
$699,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 26022573 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Cute and versatile Michiana cottage with lots of room for family and friends, just a few blocks from the neighborhood beach and parks! This 5br/2.5ba home greets you with a welcoming living area anchored by a beautiful limestone fireplace. The adjacent dining area and kitchen make an open living plan for easy entertaining. Primary bedroom on main floor opens to a spacious rec room with indoor spa and windows on three sides with great views of the backyard. Upper level bonus room with kitchenette makes a great guest or in-law suite. Huge attached garage gives you plenty of room for beach toys! Enjoy Village of Michiana pickleball courts, playground and summer day camp right around the corner, or head to the community beach for long days soaking up the sun. Extra-large lot allows for future expansion! This is a great location in a quiet, woodsy neighborhood with easy access to the local bike path, downtown New Buffalo and uptown Michigan City, all just about an hour from Chicago.

4175 Creek Drive, New Buffalo
Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.